Skip to content
Bora Haber
Markets
  • US dollar50.44up 0.05%
  • Euro55.34down 0.18%
  • British pound66.55down 0.11%
  • BIST 10011,477down 3.08%
  • Gold (gram)6,043down 3.53%
  • Gold (ounce)US$3,726down 3.58%
  • BitcoinUS$62,702down 1.5%
BREAKING

Concrete Sold as C30 Turned Out C20 in Hatay: Court Orders Foundation Demolished

In Hatay, concrete Münir Çalıcı bought as C30 tested C20 in independent analysis and C25 in an expert examination. The court ordered the foundation demolished and 680,000 TL paid.

Kerem Rüzgâr

· 2 min read

Foundation pit with rebar and standing water, excavators nearby. Below, a man in a dark sweater speaks into a microphone.
Construction foundation in Hatay, where a court ordered demolition over a concrete grade dispute. Photo: Bora Haber

In Hatay's Defne district, Münir Çalıcı, who wanted to build a workplace, won the case he filed after concrete he bought as C30 tested C20 in an independent analysis and C25 in an expert examination. The Hatay 1st Civil Court of Peace ordered the foundation built with this concrete demolished and ruled that Çalıcı be paid 680,000 TL.

Bora Haber

The legal process

Çalıcı, who lives in the Koçören neighborhood, agreed with a local concrete company to build two workplaces on his land. Out of concern about earthquakes, he paid for C30-grade concrete and received an invoice. The invoice stated that C30 concrete was used. Saying an analysis at a center outside the company found the concrete to be C20, Çalıcı started legal proceedings.

During the case, samples taken in the court process were examined, and the expert report found the concrete quality to be C25. The court ruled that there was irregularity in the quality of the concrete the company poured and ordered the foundation demolished. In the finalized ruling, 680,000 TL was awarded to Çalıcı for concrete, rebar and labor costs.

Loss calculation and objections

Çalıcı says he spent about 1 million 200 thousand TL on the foundation. He says the court's calculation took into account only items such as concrete and rebar, while costs such as electrical work, drainage pipes, plumbing, removal of the foundation excavation and rebuilding the foundation were left out. He is continuing his objections to have these items covered.

So far we calculate our loss at about 1 million 200 thousand TL. In its assessment, the court took into account about 680 thousand TL in concrete and rebar costs. We are continuing our objections so that our other expenses are covered as well.

Münir Çalıcı

Background

Çalıcı returned to his hometown after working as a truck mechanic in Saudi Arabia for more than 30 years, wanting to start his own business. He says he suspects the concrete samples went missing and applied to the prosecutor's office and the court about it. He says he no longer trusts concrete companies and will follow every stage of the new construction himself.

Agenda guides

Take a quiz, vote in a poll

Video news

Comments

Sign in to comment.

More on this topic

See all