Court of Cassation: Spouse Who Sold Gold Bracelets Must Prove They Were Gifted
The 2nd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation ruled that a man who had his wife's bracelets sold to buy a car must prove they were gifted without return, and overturned the appeals court's ruling.
· 2 min read

The 2nd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation ruled that a man who had his wife's bracelets sold to buy a car is responsible for proving that the gold was given to him as a gift with no obligation to return it. On that basis, the chamber overturned the Regional Court of Appeal's rejection decision.
The ruling came in a case over the use of wedding jewelry during a marriage. The chamber stressed that a claim that gold used to buy a car was gifted must be proven with concrete evidence, and that the burden of proof lies with the spouse who received the gold.
How the case progressed
In the divorce proceedings, filed over marital discord, the woman asked for the return of seven 22-carat bracelets of 15 grams each, which her husband had sold to buy a car. The Family Court ordered the bracelets to be handed over in kind or, if that was not possible, their value to be paid with legal interest.
After an objection, the Regional Court of Appeal concluded that the woman had given the bracelets of her own free will on the condition of not taking them back. It therefore rejected the bracelet claim and ordered only 22 quarter gold coins returned.
The Court of Cassation's assessment
Following the woman's appeal, the case reached the 2nd Civil Chamber. Reviewing the Turkish Civil Code's provisions on the burden of proof, the chamber established from both the man's own statement and records obtained from the seller's business that the seven bracelets were used to buy the car.
The ruling said the obligation to return could be lifted if it were proven that the woman had sold and spent the gold of her own will and would not ask for it back. However, the evidence in the file was said to be insufficient to show the gold was gifted to the man.
Finding no legal evidence that the seven bracelets were gifted, the chamber held that the claim should be accepted in that respect too and overturned the appeals ruling. It was thus recorded that a spouse who uses the other's jewelry to buy a vehicle or property must prove with concrete evidence that it was gifted.
Agenda guides
- How to Get a Military Service Deferment in TurkeyA deferment postpones the start of military service for legal reasons such as education or health. Student deferments are mostly processed through school notifications; you can check your status on e-Devlet.
- What documents are required to apply for marriage?Marriage applications are made to the marriage registry office. Generally, ID, a health-related document, photos and witnesses are involved; details can change, so confirm with the municipality where you apply.
- What is the Official Gazette (Resmî Gazete) and how do you read it?The Resmî Gazete is Turkey's official publication where laws, decrees, regulations and official notices are announced. Knowing its structure helps you find the text you need quickly.





Comments
Sign in to comment.