Skip to content
Bora Haber
Markets
  • US dollar50.44up 0.05%
  • Euro55.34down 0.18%
  • British pound66.55down 0.11%
  • BIST 10011,477down 3.08%
  • Gold (gram)6,043down 3.53%
  • Gold (ounce)US$3,726down 3.58%
  • BitcoinUS$62,702down 1.5%
BREAKING

Gülben Ergen brings İlber Ortaylı's remarks on nation and language to the fore

Gülben Ergen highlighted İlber Ortaylı's view that a people with its own language is a nation. Ortaylı said designations ending in '-lı, -li' are ambiguous.

Ela Sahne

· 1 min read

Blonde woman with a bob in a navy blazer, white t-shirt and gold chain necklace, against a plain white backdrop.
Debates over language and nation continue to draw wide public attention. Photo: Bora Haber

Singer and actress Gülben Ergen brought historian İlber Ortaylı's remarks on nation and language to attention. Ortaylı's words stress that a people needs a language of its own to be considered a nation.

I have told the thick-headed 50 times, those who have a language of their own are called a nation. Those ending in '-lı, -li' are ambiguous.

İlber Ortaylı

Which designations can be used?

Ortaylı said one can say Amerikalı, Kanadalı, Perulu, Pakistanlı, Avustralyalı, Arjantinli, Şilili, Yeni Zelandalı and İsviçreli. His reason was that these peoples have no languages of their own.

By contrast, he said one cannot call a German Almanyalı, a Frenchman Fransalı, an Italian İtalyalı, an Englishman İngiltereli, a Russian Rusyalı or a Japanese Japonyalı. Ortaylı likened this to not being able to call a Türk Türkiyeli.

Bora Haber previously reported: Celebrity wills: Inheritance remarks from Serdar Ortaç to Gülben Ergen.

Background

Earlier developments unrelated to these remarks show Ergen's place in public life. She played the character Melek in the series Dadı, which began airing in 2001 and was adapted from the American production The Nanny. The series ended in 2002. Ergen was also making a name in music at the time.

More recently, the singer performed at the launch of the SKY PARİS project in Ankara, singing "Hatıram Olsun" with Coşkun Sabah. At the same event she addressed the economic difficulties in the TV series sector, pointed to cost cuts and said actors should be protected.

Photo gallery4 photos

  1. Bora Haber

  2. Bora Haber

  3. Bora Haber

  4. Bora Haber

Entertainment guides

Take a quiz, vote in a poll

Video news

Comments

Sign in to comment.

More on this topic

See all