Israeli press voices concern over Myanmar ruling's impact on South Africa's genocide case
Analyses in the Israeli press say the ICJ's ruling holding Myanmar responsible for genocide could set a precedent for the case South Africa brought against Israel.
· 2 min read

Analyses published in the Israeli press assess that the genocide ruling the International Court of Justice (ICJ), the United Nations' judicial organ, issued on Myanmar could weaken Israel's position in the case South Africa brought against it. The analyses draw attention to the legal criteria the court adopted and the case law it set out.
Views highlighted in the analyses
One analysis recalls that the ICJ has for the first time in its history held a state directly responsible for the crime of genocide. It notes that the ruling came on the application of a country that is not a direct party to the conflict, which closely overlaps with South Africa's case against Israel. The same piece argues that the court relaxed the evidentiary criteria it uses to classify an act as genocide. It also says a ruling in the case against Israel is not expected before 2030, and that changes on the ICJ bench and Israel's moves in the meantime could affect the course of the process.
Another analysis argues that by widening the standards for proving the crime of genocide, the Myanmar ruling has already partly damaged Israel's ability to defend itself. It claims that, rather than focusing only on the number of people killed, the court assessed factors such as causing bodily and mental harm, widespread destruction of homes and inflammatory statements as evidence of genocidal intent, using more flexible criteria. The piece notes that UN reports weighed heavily in the Myanmar ruling and says this will create difficulty for Israel in the case it faces.
The Myanmar ruling
In the case Gambia brought against Myanmar for violating the Genocide Convention, the ICJ ruled that Myanmar committed genocide against Rohingya Muslims. The ruling assessed the Myanmar army's operations in 2016-2017. There is no appeal against the court's final decision.
Bora Haber previously reported: ICJ holds Myanmar responsible for genocide against Rohingya Muslims and Israel uploaded 3.5 million Palestinians' photos to Amazon's cloud for facial recognition.
Background
In August 2017, the Myanmar army launched "clearance operations" in northern Rakhine state. The attacks reportedly involved massacres, rapes and village burnings, and hundreds of thousands of Rohingya Muslims were forced to flee to Bangladesh. Gambia filed the genocide case against Myanmar at the ICJ on 11 November 2019.
South Africa, for its part, filed a case against Israel at the ICJ on 29 December 2023, alleging a violation of the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. Citing the urgency of the humanitarian situation in Gaza, it asked the court for provisional measures. The requests included that Israel take all necessary measures to prevent the acts defined in Article 2 of the convention, end military operations in Rafah in particular, and report regularly to the court on the measures it takes.
World guides
- What is the Organization of Turkic States and which countries are members?The Organization of Turkic States is a cooperation platform for Turkic-speaking states in political, economic and cultural fields. Its members are Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Türkiye and Uzbekistan; other actors hold observer status.
- What is NATO, which countries are members, and when did Türkiye join?NATO is an intergovernmental alliance founded by the North Atlantic Treaty of 4 April 1949. Türkiye joined on 18 February 1952, together with Greece. Check NATO and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs for the current member list.
- How does the UN Security Council work?The UN Security Council is the UN organ with primary responsibility for maintaining international peace and security. It has 15 members; 5 permanent members hold veto power, and its decisions can be binding.





Comments
Sign in to comment.