Skip to content
Bora Haber
Markets
  • US dollar50.44up 0.05%
  • Euro55.34down 0.18%
  • British pound66.55down 0.11%
  • BIST 10011,477down 3.08%
  • Gold (gram)6,043down 3.53%
  • Gold (ounce)US$3,726down 3.58%
  • BitcoinUS$62,702down 1.5%
BREAKING

Paris street interview: French citizen says "let's give America to the Native Americans too"

In a street interview in Paris, a French citizen objected to citing the presence of Jews there 3,000 years ago as grounds, and gave the example of America.

Yaman Pusula

· 1 min read

Woman with long brown hair and black top speaks into a pink microphone on a street; a bus and bus stop are behind her.
A frame from a street interview conducted in Paris. Photo: Bora Haber

In a street interview held in Paris, a French citizen objected to citing the presence of Jews there three thousand years ago as grounds for present-day claims. The citizen's remarks drew attention during the interview.

Bora Haber

If the Jews were there three thousand years ago, then let's give America to the Native Americans too.

French citizen in the interview

The citizen's example works as a comparison criticizing the use of a very old historical presence as grounds for determining present-day land ownership. Using America and Native Americans to illustrate what would follow if the same logic were applied to other countries, the citizen argued that such an approach would not be consistent.

Background

In a similar street interview recorded in Paris and focused on the Israel-Palestine issue, a French woman had also opposed Israel's historical-claim rhetoric over Palestinian lands and said the same logic should apply to the U.S. In that separate interview, she also gave the example of Germany.

In that interview on the same subject, the woman also referred to Gaza, saying, "People are being killed every day, and we act as if it is normal." These remarks, which object to determining today's borders and property on historical grounds, are part of a separate debate on the same topic rather than of the event reported here. The two interviews show how historical claims are being debated on Paris streets around the Israel-Palestine issue.

World guides

Take a quiz, vote in a poll

Video news

Comments

Sign in to comment.

More on this topic

See all